Table 4.
Civic expert system in local governments II

Category Changwon(창원시) Sungnam(성남시) Hwasung(화성시) Gumi(구미시)
Population 1.03 million 0.93 million 0.82 million 0.42 million
Law Changwon City ordinance (성남시 건축 기본 조례) Sungnam City ordinance (성남시 건축 기본 조례) On process (조례 제정 중) Gumi City regulation (구미시 총괄건축가 및 공공건축가 운영 규정)
MA(총괄건축가)
Name MA(총괄건축가) MA(총괄건축가) MP(총괄계획가) MA(총괄건축가)
Position Vice mayor(부시장급) Vice mayor(부시장급) - Vice mayor(부시장급)
Appointment Open recruitment Open recruitment Recommendation(지명추천) Recommendation
Organization Architecture landscape dept.(건축경관과) Architecture dept. (건축과 공공건축디자인팀) Urban housing Bureau (도시주택국 도시디자인과) Urban regeneration dept. (도시재생과)
Term 2 years/consecutive 2 years/consecutive 2 years 2 years/consecutive
Payment Chief engineer (엔지니어링/기술사 수준) Chief engineer (엔지니어링/기술사 수준) - Chief engineer (엔지니어링/기술사 수준)
Number 1/0 1/0 4/3 1/0
General architect(공공건축가)
Name General architect(공공건축가) General architect(공공건축가) - General architect(공공건축가)
Appointment Open recruitment Open recruitment - Recruitment
Organization Architecture landscape dept.(건축경관과) Architecture dept. (건축과 공공건축디자인팀) - Urban regeneration dept. (도시재생과)
Term 2 years/consecutive 2 years/consecutive - 2 years/consecutive
Payment Consultancy fee (엔지니어링/기술사 기준) Consultancy fee (엔지니어링/기술사 기준) - Consultancy fee (엔지니어링/기술사 기준)
Employment 22/1 14/1 - 5/1